1. My order for comedies:

1. Flight of the Conchords
Curb Your Enthusiasm
The Office
30 Rock
5. Family Guy

Posted at 8:43PM on Jun 26th 2008 by ggo

2. Not bad. Not bad at all. I'll be rooting for Lost and Pushing Daisies in their respective categories. Also I love all the awards love the latter is getting despite only getting a few episodes to show its muscles. Looking forward to a full season of Daisies next year.

Posted at 8:45PM on Jun 26th 2008 by Ryan

3. Family Guy? Really?

Posted at 8:56PM on Jun 26th 2008 by Oreo

4. Hope flight of the conchords get a nomination!!!

Posted at 9:15PM on Jun 26th 2008 by nattyff

5. I want to see Lost and Flight of the Conchords win!!!

Posted at 9:48PM on Jun 26th 2008 by TGrace

6. Definitely cheering for Flight of the Chonchords :D

Posted at 10:00PM on Jun 26th 2008 by SirCrumpet

7. THE WIRE THE WIRE THE WIRE THE WIRE THE WIRE THE WIRE THE WIRE THE WIRE THE WIRE THE WIRE THE WIRE THE WIRE THE WIRE THE WIRE THE WIRE THE WIRE

Posted at 10:14PM on Jun 26th 2008 by dtpollitt

8. Yes, Family Guy. http://www.variety.com/article/VR1117986706.html?categoryid=14&cs=1&nid=2565

Posted at 10:27PM on Jun 26th 2008 by Elf

9. Long story short, Battlestar Galactica gets frakked again. Of the top 10 dramas, the only series that deserved to be there are The Wire, Mad Men and Lost. The rest had mediocre seasons at best, especially Greys Anatomy and Boston Legal.

Posted at 11:11PM on Jun 26th 2008 by Jimmy

10. I'll agree with most of your comment, but Damages and House had far from mediocre seasons. House's job-hunt arc revitalized the show, and Damages was just plain amazing.

Posted at 5:50AM on Jun 27th 2008 by Pinwiz

11. My top 5 dramas on this Emmy list are
LOST
Mad Men
Friday Night Lights
The Wire
Dexter

Comedies
30 Rock (Hands down the funniest on the list)

Posted at 12:48AM on Jun 27th 2008 by Jeff N.

12. Lost is the best drama AND the best comedy. It has everything.

Posted at 1:40AM on Jun 27th 2008 by CJH

13. Even though the second season was not as strong as the first I would love to see Friday Night Lights get a nomination, that show is my favorite. It would also be nice to see The Wire get some love. I must be missing out on Boston Legal it doesn't look interesting to me but it seems like it is always winning something, maybe I should check it out?

Posted at 4:25AM on Jun 27th 2008 by BDUB

14. My top 5
1. 30 Rock
2.The Office
3.Weeds
4.Ugly Betty
5.Curb Your Enthusiasm

Posted at 4:41AM on Jun 27th 2008 by erik

15. Wow. I love television comedy and I don't watch any of them on that list. Even worse, I absolutely hate a few of those. Family Guy? Really?
I'm disappointed that How I Met Your Mother isn't on the list.

Posted at 8:08AM on Jun 27th 2008 by Dave

16. The only way Dexter is not in someone's top 5 is if they've never seen the show.

I so hope Michael C. Hall gets the recognition this year too. While I absolutely adore Hugh Laurie... Hall takes the cake. and sometimes the arms... always a slide of blood...

Tudors was good, but not great this season. I really really enjoyed Lost though, and feel its rightfully deserved.

I tried but could never get into Mad Men or Damages. I know I know sue me.

From what I hear, the Wire is the best show ever made, and I'll definitely start checking it out, one day.

Posted at 10:07AM on Jun 27th 2008 by cdawg

17. No BSG or Brothers and Sisters. Who makes these selections? In any case, Lost and 30 Rock should win their respective categories hands down.

Posted at 10:50AM on Jun 27th 2008 by Jennifer

18. Oh please God let The Wire win this year. It won't have any more chances, and everyone who worked on that show really deserves it. I also hope Andre Royo gets an acting nomination...he has been phenomenal.

My choices for top Drama:
-The Wire
-Mad Men
-Dexter
-FNL

BSG would be my 5th choice. I haven't seen any of the others on the list so can't say anything about them.

The comedy list is awesome! FOTC, The Office, 30 Rock and CYE have all been excellent.

Posted at 10:53AM on Jun 27th 2008 by SJ

19. Academy members are so male dominated -- they overlooked The Adventures of Old Christine which was on usatoday's and EW's list of who should be nominated for the top 5. And what does How I met your mother not get nominated again?? At least, they didn't nominate overpraised The big bang theory. But I hope that James Roday of Psych, sinjin kim of Lost make the final list for acting nominees.

Posted at 1:31PM on Jun 27th 2008 by Sam

20. The common misconception about How I Met Your Mother is that it's funny. The only reason I can get through an episode is Jason Segal and NPH. As for New Adventures of Old Christine, why is Entertainment Weekly suddenly reputable?

These lists are fairly accurate and represent the best of what is out there.

Posted at 12:44PM on Jun 28th 2008 by Jesse